Although there are varying
opinions in the scientific community about whether or not shark attacks
are in increasing, there are a number of factors that make humans more
vulnerable to shark attacks, and these are factors that we can change
or at least control.
A shark
attack on humans is motivated by two general causes. The first cause is
feeding, when the shark is looking for food and either bites the human
victim or swallows him whole. The second cause for shark attacks is
when the shark is not hunting for food, but views man as a threat.
According to Bernard J. Zahuranec, author of Shark Repellents of
the Sea, shark generally feed on smaller prey, and they bite or
gouge pieces of dead or injured animals. Distress signals also capture
the interest of sharks. Strange odors, sounds, and erratic movements
can attract sharks, and even lead to a feeding frenzy, when many sharks
attack at once. Attacks are sudden and fast; the snout of the shark is
lifted, the pectoral fin is exaggerated, and the back is arched. The
shark does not forewarn of an attack. Zahuranec mentions two men, H.D
Baldridge and J. Williams, authors of the article “Shark Attack:
Feeding or Fighting?” for the International Shark Attack Files. They
say, “Results of aggressive behavior directed at victims is an attitude
of fighting rather than feeding.” According to Baldridge and Williams,
many victims had slash wounds, not consistent w/ the attempt to remove
flesh (Zahuranec 14).
Hunger is
one reason for attacks. Searching for prey is a shark’s primary
objective, according to Paul Budker, author of Life of Sharks.
Budker says that sharks even show interest in attacking boats when they
are hungry. Along the Australian shore, attacks on boats seem to occur
where bathers do not generally go, but where the white shark abounds.
Fishing boats are believed to be attacked more often because of the
presence of fish on lines and fish already dead and in the boat. Budker
says sharks must have an incredible sense of smell for them to be able
to detect the fish in the boats. However, Dr. David Coppleson, author
of Shark Attack, records that even canoes and racing boats have
been attacked. Budker also says that sharks looking to mate can be more
irritable and aggressive. Experimental studies on the mating habits of
sharks have been difficult to carry out, and little is known about this
subject.
Also,
water temperature has an effect on sharks. Dr. Coppleson says that the
water temperature that sharks seem to favor is around seventy degrees
farinheight. If water temperature is above this, attacks may occur.
Because of this, shark attacks are more likely to occur in warm summer
months.
According
to Budker, the fear of attacks is out of proportion to the risks. He
says that shark attacks must be ranked far below the causes of
premature death, car accidents, alcoholism, smoking, and rabid dogs
(Budker 134).
According
to Jose Castro, author of Sharks of the North American Waters,
humans are not included in any shark’s diet. Castro says that sharks
and their eating habits evolved many years before man existed. Sharks
feed on fish and other marine animals. Attacks on humans usually only
happen when a person is handling a hooked shark or when spear fisherman
are handling fish. Castro also says sharks have acute senses to detect
wounded or dying fish, and they attack them because they are easier to
catch, and this preserves their energy. Sharks must also balance their
energy between chasing and capturing prey. A wounded fish lets of
olfactory, auditory, electric, and visual stimuli that attract the
shark, and the shark may attack a fisherman handling the wounded prey.
A diver’s behavior can also attract sharks. Divers in black wet suits,
letting out bubbles, and splashing on the surface, resembling a seal
will attract sharks, and an attack may occur. Sharks usually do not
pursue the attack after the initial bite, perhaps because sharks do not
like the taste of human flesh. Sharks in a feeding frenzy may indeed
devour victims of plane and boat disasters, however, a clear case of
intentional attack on humans. And finally, according to Castro, sharks
may be territorial, causing problems for divers and swimmers.
On the
other hand, according to Victor G. Springer and Joy P. Gold, authors of
Sharks in Question, sharks do pose a threat to humans in water.
Shark attacks may have increased, and if so, the increase may be due to
an increase in the number of people participating in water sports.
Springer and Gold also suggest that as a result of the Marine Mammal
Protection Act of 1973, there may be in increase in population of
certain species of sharks and a population increase in other marine
animals that sharks feed on. Springer and Gold also suggest that there
may not be an increase in attacks, but an increase in the attacks being
reported. Whatever the reasons for attack, they agree chances of attack
are not great (Springer and Gold 133).
According
to Springer and Gold, biologists are not exactly sure why sharks attack
humans. It is known that sounds and movement will attract sharks, but
little is known about what happens when sharks become hungry.
Baldridge, writing for the “Shark Attack Files,” estimates that from
half to three-quarters of shark attacks on humans may have been attacks
that had nothing to do with feeding.
Sharks may
mistake a surfer for a seal, or splashing swimmers for fish. Even
normal human body secretions may be an attractant for sharks. Sharks
usually bump or ram into a victim before taking a bite out of them.
When ramming or bumping, victims will have lacerations and abrasions,
which is sometimes considered an attack. Also, because bites on victims
are similar to the courtship bites of males on females, even sex has
been considered a motivation factor. Springer and Gold also agree with
Castro that sharks may be territorial and perceive humans as a threat,
and therefore attack.
In David
Capuzzo’s book, Close to Shore, shark expert Dr. Lucus reasoned
that given the weakness of even the largest shark’s jaws, a man would
lose a leg only “if a shark thirty feet or more in length happened to
catch the man fairly close to the knee joint where no severing of the
bone was necessary (Capuzzo 182). In reference to the 1916 New Jersey
attacks, a series of shark attacks along the Jersey shore; a shark was
not capable of biting cleanly through the bone and therefore could not
have been the animal that bit off the legs below the knee of a victim.
He also says, “certainly no shark recorded as having been taken in
these waters could possibly perform such an act ( Capuzzo 182).
Coppleson believed shark attacks began with rising popularity of
beaches for recreational use at the turn of the century. He says water
temperature can now explain cluster attacks.
Capuzzo
also says that scientists have found evidence that sharks attack more
frequently during very high tides caused by gravitational pull of the
moon. A preliminary study by researchers at the “Shark Attack Files”
has found worldwide correlation between “the phases of the moon, the
height of the tides, and the frequency of shark attacks (Capuzzo 228).
George Burgess, president of the “Shark Attack Files” says researchers
are still studying this phenomenon.
Many of
these researchers, shark experts, and biologists share the same
thoughts on why sharks attack and the likelihood of an attack. Most
agree that sharks do not attack because they want to eat humans, but
they attack because they may be territorial, defensive, mistaking
humans for seals, and because they smell fish in the vicinity of
humans. They also agree that a person is thirty times more likely to be
struck by lightning than attacked by a shark. Researchers also say that
sharks have incredible senses and can detect dead or injured fish. One
must assume that a shark, with all his keen smell senses, should be
able to detect the odor of a human and back off before an attack. There
is no scientific explanation of why sharks still attack humans, despite
their keen sense of smell.
Some say
shark attack numbers have not risen greatly, that the numbers are still
low. According to the Time article, “Why Can’t We Be Friends? A
Horrific attack raises old fears, but new research reveals surprising
keys to shark behavior,” shark attacks have been on the rise in recent
years. However, the numbers remain minuscule compared to the number of
deaths caused by car accidents, drug overdose, lightning strikes, and
other causes of death. In 2000, there were seventy-nine unprovoked
attacks compared with the fifty-eight attacks in 1999, and fifty-four
in 1998. Two-thirds of these attacks happened in U.S waters, on
surfers, boogie-boarders and swimmers. The article also states that one
is more likely to be killed by lightning-thirty times to be exact.
Ironically, people seem to be more frightened by the thought of being
eaten by a shark than by being struck by lightning. Perhaps is it
simply the gruesomeness of a shark attack that is so upsetting.
In the
same Time article, researchers say that usually younger,
inexperienced sharks attack humans, and they are not sure why. Most
researchers think that sharks can detect the difference between the
taste of human flesh, and they spit out human flesh.
Researchers
also say that there has been an increase in shark attacks in Hawaii,
which may be due to the increase in sea turtles. The turtles swim close
to shore and the sharks feed on them, this bringing them closer to
human swimmers. The human victims of shark attacks are intruders rather
than targeted prey.
Attacks
also occur because of shark feeding tours. Scientists know how
dangerous sharks can be, and are critical of these tours. Sharks know
the sounds of motors on boats and associate the sounds with food.
According
to the article “Harvest of Blame” in National Fisherman,
over-fishing is increasing the number of shark attacks. Severe federal
restrictions on shark harvesting in the gulf and the Atlantic, along
with increasing lure of the bait-filled sanctuaries in Florida, have
greatly increased the number of attacks and the chances of interaction
with the humans. Danny Raffield, part owner of Raffield Fisheries, says
that there is no shark fishing activity in Florida to scare the sharks
off.
A new
University of Florida study shows that the annual 2001 total of
seventy-two six unprovoked attacks worldwide was less than the
eighty-five recorded in 200, and fatalities declined from twelve to
five in the same period, according to George Burgess, director of the
“Shark Attack Files.” Perhaps the media has reported on the attacks
more because the attacks have been on younger children, such as Jessie
Arbogast in Florida. A shark while swimming attacked the little boy.
Media has definitely played a major part in frightening the public
about shark attacks, even though shark attack numbers have stayed the
same through out the recent years. Shark attacks do appear to be out of
hunger, defense, and simple mistake. Sharks do have an acute sense of
smell, which is why it is confusing as to why they still attack humans.
In our
minds, sharks represent s clear and present danger while we are out it
the oceans. Humans tend to have an unreasonable fear and hatred towards
sharks. Many of us no very little scientific knowledge of sharks, so we
are emotional when it comes to shark attacks and what the media has to
say about them. Jaws movies as well as in increase in the
media attention given to sharks and shark attacks over the years has
caused humans to fear and despise sharks. People are more of afraid of
shark attacks than they are of dying because of drunk drivers,
lightning, drugs, and car accidents. Perhaps this is because sharks are
other living, breathing creatures, and we as humans recognize that
killing is a horrible action, as well as because of the media attention
given to sharks.
Despite
shark attacks, some people feel that one is venturing into shark
territory when entering the ocean. Even some victims of shark attacks
share this view. Jonothan Mozo, a Hawaiian photographer who lives in
Oahu was surfing one morning and was attacked. He says, “I have no hard
feelings of hatred against the sharks. I don’t want revenge. I don’t
think they should be eliminated. We are not masters of the sea. If it
were our territory we’d have been born with gills and fins. I was out
there a guest in his world. I just feel lucky enough he let me live.”